Best Insurance Companies 2025
Top-rated insurance providers based on customer satisfaction, financial strength, and claims handling
How We Rate Insurance Companies
Customer Satisfaction
Based on verified reviews and J.D. Power ratings
Financial Strength
A.M. Best ratings for stability and reliability
Claims Handling
Speed and ease of claims processing
Affordability
Competitive pricing and discount availability
USAA
Customer Satisfaction
Claims Handling
Affordability
Financial Strength
A++
Pros
- •Consistently lowest rates for eligible members
- •Exceptional customer service
- •Easy claims process
- •Comprehensive coverage options
Cons
- •Only available to military members and families
- •Limited physical branch locations
Best For:
Military members and their families seeking comprehensive coverage and excellent service
State Farm
Customer Satisfaction
Claims Handling
Affordability
Financial Strength
A++
Pros
- •Largest network of agents (19,000+)
- •Wide range of coverage options
- •Good customer service and support
- •Multiple discount opportunities
Cons
- •Rates may be higher in some states
- •Claims process can vary by agent
Best For:
Customers who prefer working with local agents and need multiple policy types
Geico
Customer Satisfaction
Claims Handling
Affordability
Financial Strength
A++
Pros
- •Competitive rates and discounts
- •User-friendly mobile app
- •Fast quote process (15 minutes)
- •24/7 customer service
Cons
- •Limited physical agent availability
- •Fewer coverage customization options
Best For:
Budget-conscious drivers looking for straightforward coverage and digital convenience
Progressive
Customer Satisfaction
Claims Handling
Affordability
Financial Strength
A+
Pros
- •Name Your Price tool for customization
- •Snapshot telematics program (up to 30% savings)
- •Comprehensive coverage for specialty vehicles
- •Strong online experience
Cons
- •Customer service ratings lag competitors
- •Rates can increase at renewal
Best For:
Drivers who want usage-based insurance and flexible pricing options
Allstate
Customer Satisfaction
Claims Handling
Affordability
Financial Strength
A+
Pros
- •Drivewise program with up to 40% savings
- •Strong network of local agents
- •Accident forgiveness options
- •New car replacement coverage
Cons
- •Higher average premiums
- •Mixed customer service reviews
Best For:
Drivers interested in usage-based savings and comprehensive coverage features
Nationwide
Customer Satisfaction
Claims Handling
Affordability
Financial Strength
A+
Pros
- •Vanishing deductible program
- •Strong multi-policy discounts
- •Excellent pet insurance options
- •SmartRide telematics program
Cons
- •Limited availability in some states
- •Customer service wait times can be long
Best For:
Families looking for bundled coverage including pet insurance
Need Help Choosing?
Our licensed insurance experts can help you compare carriers and find the best coverage for your needs.